Ugly populism has won the day

Clare Condon SGS

Clare Condon SGS

People who seek asylum are not ‘illegals’. They are human beings, just like you and me, writes Good Samaritan Sister, Clare Condon.

BY Clare Condon SGS*

This week, on June 20, people of goodwill worldwide will take time to commemorate World Refugee Day. Held annually, it’s an opportunity to draw attention to the plight of people who have been forced to flee their homes due to fear of persecution.

According to the United Nations Refugee Agency, “more that 42 million people around the world have been forcibly displaced from their homes and communities”. That’s close to double Australia’s total population.

So why is it that Australia is so miserly, to say the least, in welcoming refugees and asylum seekers to this land of opportunity and extraordinary natural wealth? Why are we being mean-spirited, fearful and condemnatory, especially to those who desperately risk entry to Australia by a treacherous sea journey? Why is the focus of national debate on the people-traffickers and not on the desperate people being trafficked?

The Refugee Council of Australia says that, in 2012, a mere 14,415 people arrived on our shores by boat. That’s only 0.06 per cent increase in our population. The arrival of refugees over the past ten years has been during a period when Australians have enjoyed continuous growth in Gross National Product (GNP). At this current time, the nation has one of the lowest unemployment rates in the developed world.

In the past two weeks we have witnessed another 55 people perish in Australian waters. They died an ignominious death – no names and no retrieved bodies. People with no identity! And yet, they were someone’s husband, wife, brother, sister or child. They took desperate risks, hoping against hope for a new life. They are now dead.

People who seek asylum are not ‘illegals’. They are human beings, just like you and me, who, through circumstances of birth or nationality, find themselves in intolerable positions of war, civil unrest, dictatorships and persecution. This can be difficult to comprehend for someone born and bred in Australia.

So why does our government treat them in such a punitive way? The policy of detention keeps them as statistics, out of sight from most Australians. They are rendered invisible. Without any citizenship rights, they have no power within the electoral process. Their stories are not told, so their stories are not heard by Australian citizens. Therefore, they can be easily demonised and tragically stereotyped.

It was in August 2001, during the infamous Tampa event, that electoral cynicism, fear and denigration exposed a deeply flawed aspect of Australia’s national character. In the intervening years, it seems that cynicism and fear have prevailed. Ugly populism has won the day! Any spirit of goodwill and basic hospitality to our global neighbours has evaporated. The spirit of a ‘fair go’ and justice has disappeared from the national discourse.

I fully support the principle that each sovereign nation has the right and responsibility to regulate the entry of people into its nation. But such regulation must be just and fair, not punitive. It should not impose physical and psychological harm upon innocent people, especially children. Extended detention does such harm. A policy that prevents asylum seekers released into the community from working in order to provide for the well-being of themselves and their families, is destructive of them and diminishes us as a nation.

It seems that while we as a nation are seeking to redress the atrocities of the past, such as the treatment of our First Peoples and the transportation of young children from Post World War II Britain, the current regime of detaining refugees and asylum seekers, especially of women and children, is continuing such atrocities. Have we not learnt anything?

Statistics have never changed the hearts of people. Stories do. If we could find a way to bring the real ‘boat people’ out of the darkness of detention into the visibility of the community, there could be opportunities for them to tell us their stories. Then, maybe, the conscience of the nation might be re-discovered. There would be no place for the rhetoric of “turn back the boats” or “off-shore processing”, but rather, let’s support these people and welcome them as true neighbours. Different ways could be found for bringing them safely to this land of plenty.

* Clare Condon is the Congregational Leader of the Sisters of the Good Samaritan of the Order of St Benedict.

Download a printer-friendly version (PDF 74KB)

The Good Oil, June 18, 2013

5 Responses to “Ugly populism has won the day”

  1. Helen Flett says:

    It seems to me that even when we do accept refugees to our greatly blessed country, we do not give them anywhere near the support they desperately need to be integrated successfully and peacefully into our Australian community. A whole new source of employment opportunities could be developed for ongoing education, assistance, counselling, guidance etc. This needs to be a two-way venture to be inclusive of people already living here with no or little understanding of the plight of refugees, their backgrounds, the dilemmas of their lives thus far.

  2. Peter says:

    Not a week goes by without the Catholic Leader spilling their blood for the “Illegal Criminal Boat People”. As these people have arrived firstly in “Safe Haven” where a country will not prosecute them, why do they pay $6000 to $10,000 to a Criminal People Smuggler by flying onto Indonesia. If these Aliens are REAL refugees they would fly direct to Australia for under $2000, NOT fly to Indonesia and pay $6 to $10,000 to come by a Criminal boat smuggler. To land in Indonesia would require a Passport, yet when these criminals arrive here, they have no documents, yet our so called bleeding hearts here in Australia, who no doubt are paid to blah, blah, by the government or the Church want the country to be flooded by these Aliens. The Catholic Church and its so called pastoral bleeding hearts depts. should be disbanded. I am tired of being lectured by so called Catholic lay people and Religious about how awful my Country is towards Illegal Criminals. I DO NOT WANT ANY MORE MOSLEMS in MY country. I do not want these people here! If you do then go to where they come. Yes! the old cry of “You are a racist and and non Christian blah, blah, etc. I do not care what people think. I am affronted when I see a moving object clad in black cloth head to foot……..I am affronted when I see these Aliens living exactly the way in my country as they did in the country they could not stand to live in. I am affronted by the bleeding hearts not crying for the Christians in these Middle Age countries. The number of these Criminals is not 14,000 but 40,000!!!!!!!! I DO NOT WANT MY COUNTRY FLOODED BY MOSLEMS! We cannot feed the World!

  3. Col O'Brien says:

    Heartening to see over 2,000 people attending the Lantern Procession at South Bank in Brisbane in support of refugees and asylum seekers. I with other Good Sams felt privileged to carry banners as we joined in the walk.

  4. Marie Jones says:

    Clare, BRAVA!!!!!!!! Thank you!

  5. Margaret says:

    I agree with the power of story telling to start a different conversation.

Leave a Comment