Feel the pain, heal the damage

Photo credit: Freeimages.com/Caetano Lacerda

This year the pain of the passion story may contain a deeper significance than ever before, says Tony Doherty. And with it a new sense of adult responsibility we all bear to remake this harsh and gentle world.

By Tony Doherty*

If today you are asked to place this world of ours on the scale of “good or bad”, to which side of the scales would your opinion tip?

Faced with the breakdown of institutions, the hypocrisy of those we have trusted, the total lunacy of world leaders, the violent destruction of lives and entire cities, the explosion of illegal drugs, the balance shifts alarmingly to one side.

And yet, there is a quieter evidence, admittedly far less spectacular, of the undoubted goodness we are capable of, the patient compassion, the determination to take responsibility for our actions, acts of breathless generosity and at times immense creativity – such qualities somehow survive. Garrison Keillor catches it: “Even in a time of elephantine vanity and greed, one never has to look far to see the campfires of gentle people”.

But then come the catastrophic findings of the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse. As a priest, I must sadly admit, it is hard to think about ‘gentle campfires’.

Despite all the warnings, the results have been devastating.

Trying to wrap your imagination around the damage that has been done to the lives of so many innocent children, many of whom now suffer seriously reduced adult lives, damage that is sometimes unable to be repaired – seems an impossible task.

And yet it is imperative to do so.

All of us, but particularly those like myself involved in formal ministry in this church, need to feel the pain. Stay with the cry of those who have been damaged. Find some way to heal the harm. Is this church, which we love, the bandage or the wound?

It is crucial that we stay with the reality and not search for some hasty defence of what has happened. The analgesic society we inhabit doesn’t help. Avoidance of pain has become an industry. We are practiced in dodging discomfort. The ability to distract ourselves comes home delivered through 103 channels. There is always the next crisis to divert our attention. Turn on the footy. Another white wine. If all else fails there remains the crowded shelves of our local pharmacies to dull the ache.

Our church has to face nothing less than the reality of major surgery. And its consequent pain. No simple regime of little pink pills will deal with this tumour. Getting back to business as usual is an unthinkable option.

How to genuinely address the needs of those damaged, or even their wounded families, needs the clearest and courageous imaginative action – firstly by those of us sharing some form of leadership in this shell-shocked church, but also by all of us who choose to engage with a new responsible adult community of faith.

It will take uncommonly honest reflection, the clearest minds, and inspired leadership – of both women and men. It will also take balance and the steady hands of a surgeon.

Pain can be destructive. Pain, however, can also contain the energy required for this massive task.

A former Anglican bishop Richard Holloway spells out in the following words the stormy waters in which we all swim, and in the midst of which we strive to find our sanity, our balance and the energy to navigate a new future. His words capture, in my opinion, what is best understood as the virtue of hope – genuinely adult, not sentimentalised Christian hope.

“It is a harsh world indescribably cruel.
It is a gentle world unbelievably beautiful.
It is a world that can make us bitter, hateful, rabid
destroyers of joy.
It is a world that can draw out tenderness in us as we lean
towards each other over broken gates.
It is a world of monsters and saints, a mutilated world,
but it is the only one we have been given.
We should let it shock us not into hatred and anxiety, but into
unconditional love.”

Easter is celebrated in a few weeks. This year the pain of the passion story may contain a deeper significance than ever before. And with it a new sense of adult responsibility we all bear to remake this harsh and gentle world.

* Father Tony Doherty is a retired priest of the Sydney Archdiocese. Throughout his 50-plus years as a priest, he has written and published widely, in a quest to demystify religious language. This article was first published on Tony Doherty’s blog on March 6, 2017.

Download a printer-friendly version (PDF 168KB)


The Good Oil, March 21, 2017. If you would like to republish this article, please contact the editor.

2 Responses to “Feel the pain, heal the damage”

  1. kevin Treston says:

    Yes, Tony, thanks for the article. On one level our media is full of awful stories (even this morning, the attack in London). For Catholics, as you write, the Royal Commission findings, are really shocking. Yet, as you say, as Easter people, we look towards the possibility of a new beginning.

    Thank you for your realism and hope to strive for a gentler world.
    (voice from the past Tony! Remember the adult education days in Sydney)

  2. Marie Casamento says:

    Yes Tony I heartily agree we must indeed stay with the reality, the reality of the church inflicting such life time wounds on innocent children. It is only in our ability to accept the reality that we give hope to future generations that each child will be safe. Marie

Leave a Comment

The aim of The Good Oil's comment section is to encourage respectful conversation and dialogue. When posting your comment please:

  • be brief (no more than 120 words) and keep on topic;
  • be respectful of others whether you agree with their opinion or not;
  • be careful about posting your personal information online.

Our comment section is moderated. Your name and email are required for identification purposes. Your email will not be published. We reserve the right to not publish comments.